Bookmark managers being a separate application is a brilliant idea. Like password managers, they can be full blown standalone applications, with lots of functionality and variability.
I wish Firefox and others had good IPC for external applications to function as bookmark manager, password manager, etc. Browsers can then focus on being browsers, and we have have a variety of external bookmark managers exploring different design ideas, or focusing on different workflows.
For sure! I briefly looked into integrating more with browsers, for example, to better what's currently opened in different windows. But so far the only way I found was to rely heavily on macOS accessibility API to get some bi-directional data flow between the browser and the external app.
Or alternatively try to do this kind of integration via a browser extension. I know Raycast is doing something similar with their browser extension, when the extension acts as a proxy between the app and the browser to deliver different context to the app
I always have a love hate relationship with bookmarks. I tend to treat bookmarks as a write once read never datastore. I have a set of 2-3 bookmarklets that I use often, but almost never use other bookmarks. I do keep an archive of pages or links I find interesting, but I store those in a separate archive (self hosted Karakeep).
So, I’m legitimately curious — for the author or others — how do you use bookmarks? What is your personal usage pattern? Do you have many pages you need to keep track of? Is there much churn or adding of new bookmarks? I’d like to make beater use of my stored links, but right now it is really a write-only archive.
I use bookmark tags a lot, and rely on them to quickly find things in future.
I bookmark all sorts of things. Projects or articles that I think I'll likely need in future, issues which I report and might need to reference in future, etc.
I'm sure over 50% of my bookmark were written and never read, but I definitely query all sorts of old bookmarks nearly every day.
I built a simple bookmarks app for myself and others, which sends you a weekly recap of what you saved and finds things from your archive you might want to revisit. Would love your feedback: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/eyeball-bookmarks-assistant/id...
Thank you! I have similar issues with bookmark managers overall. When they are too far from where I use them, it turns into a list of links I never read
In Arc, I'd organize links in dedicated workspaces for each project (personal or work). So whenever I work on a specific project, I'd open that workspace and have all the necessary links right there. For example, I tend to check Product Hunt often, and I have a dedicated workspace where I'd store products organized by my personal use cases. So next time I'm looking for a tool for something, I'd just open that workspace and search
I use Obsidian (other note-taking apps and editor modes are available) and generally write at least a sentence about each bookmark. Subject areas get their own notes/bookmarks and I use the available linking and tagging options to try to make the resource more useful and easier to refer to in the future.
I noticed there is an Always on Top option in Settings, but I cannot enable it. Do I need to grant any additional permissions?
Also, it would be great if the app could read bookmarks from other browsers and support cloud syncing of the JSON file via WebDAV.
Right now Always on Top options can be enabled only when you're not in the "attachment mode". Because when the app is attached to browser window it shows the sidebar only when it becomes active. I'll see if I can find some solution
As for importing from other browsers, this is definitely on my list (at least Chrome and Firefox). I just did Arc first because that's where I wanted to migrate from
How do you feel about Safari tab groups? They're perfectly happy to snap open a thousand tabs at once, from however many such groups you like, all synced across all the (Apple) devices. And on the left of the Safari window in a sliding tray.
Aside from these groups, there's "Save all open tabs to a Bookmarks folder" which lets you just shove a few hundred or thousand tabs into a bookmarks folder every few weeks or months.
Given the old limits on these, it's remarkable how much work they put into tab hoarding enabling!
Thank you!
Yeah I tried Zen a while ago. It was generally awesome and I saw they invested a lot in the experience lately. Need to give it another try for sure
If only it wasn't Firefox-based, that would have been perfect :)
I wish Firefox and others had good IPC for external applications to function as bookmark manager, password manager, etc. Browsers can then focus on being browsers, and we have have a variety of external bookmark managers exploring different design ideas, or focusing on different workflows.
Or alternatively try to do this kind of integration via a browser extension. I know Raycast is doing something similar with their browser extension, when the extension acts as a proxy between the app and the browser to deliver different context to the app
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Mozilla/Add-ons/Web...
I always have a love hate relationship with bookmarks. I tend to treat bookmarks as a write once read never datastore. I have a set of 2-3 bookmarklets that I use often, but almost never use other bookmarks. I do keep an archive of pages or links I find interesting, but I store those in a separate archive (self hosted Karakeep).
So, I’m legitimately curious — for the author or others — how do you use bookmarks? What is your personal usage pattern? Do you have many pages you need to keep track of? Is there much churn or adding of new bookmarks? I’d like to make beater use of my stored links, but right now it is really a write-only archive.
I bookmark all sorts of things. Projects or articles that I think I'll likely need in future, issues which I report and might need to reference in future, etc.
I'm sure over 50% of my bookmark were written and never read, but I definitely query all sorts of old bookmarks nearly every day.
In Arc, I'd organize links in dedicated workspaces for each project (personal or work). So whenever I work on a specific project, I'd open that workspace and have all the necessary links right there. For example, I tend to check Product Hunt often, and I have a dedicated workspace where I'd store products organized by my personal use cases. So next time I'm looking for a tool for something, I'd just open that workspace and search
As for importing from other browsers, this is definitely on my list (at least Chrome and Firefox). I just did Arc first because that's where I wanted to migrate from
Aside from these groups, there's "Save all open tabs to a Bookmarks folder" which lets you just shove a few hundred or thousand tabs into a bookmarks folder every few weeks or months.
Given the old limits on these, it's remarkable how much work they put into tab hoarding enabling!
It's quite an early version, but I've been using it for the last few days and it's really nice to have bookmarks so close to the browser
(I don’t want to be “that guy” but are you aware of the Zen Browser? It was a drop in replacement for me and I love it)